>Optical Disc Drives - North Dakota
Date Filed: April 6, 2010
Court: U.S. District Court
Location: California

Hagens Berman has filed a class-action lawsuit against the producers of optical disc drives (ODD) alleging that the companies illegally manipulated the prices of the drives.

According to the suit, these anticompetitive practices have caused consumers of a wide range of products including computers, video game consoles and CD, DVD and Blu-ray players to overpay for the devices.

Consumers in North Dakota who own one or more of these devices are encouraged to contact the Hagens Berman legal team to discuss their legal options as part of a nationwide legal action against the ODD manufacturers, which include Sony (NYSE: SNE), Hitachi (NYSE: HIT) and Philips (NYSE: PHG).

Consumers interested in learning more can join the case online by clicking here.

UPDATES: 

June 4, 2010 – United States District Chief Judge Vaughn R. Walker appointed Steve Berman and Jeff Friedman with Hagens Berman as interim class counsel, representing plaintiffs in the class-action lawsuit filed against ODD makers in April 2010. According to the court order, the final appointment of class counsel will be made when and if a class of indirect purchaser plaintiffs is certified.

June 24, 2010 - Judge Walker believed the broad stay of discovery DOJ requested was not justified here. The court intends to allow the normal evidence discovery process to proceed against the likes of Sony, Samsung and other optical disc drive makers, and address any specific concerns raised by the government if and when they arise.



Key Attorneys

Ivy Arai Tabbara
Ivy Arai Tabbara is a partner at Hagens Berman’s Seattle office. Ms. Tabbara’s practice focuses...   link >>
Steve W. Berman
Mr. Berman co-founded the firm in 1993, and is the managing partner. He is considered one of the most succe...   link >>
Jeff D. Friedman

Mr. Friedman is a former federal prosecutor and currently a partner in Hagens Berman’s San Francisco office, where he specializes in class actions against some of the largest companies in the United States. He litigates cases involving antitrust violations, securities fraud, and consumer protection matters.

Mr. Friedman’s antitrust practice includes litigation against technology companies and cutting-edge competition policy issues. Mr. Friedman is part of our team of lawyers in the following cases in which Hagens Berman is lead or co-lead counsel:

  • In re Electronic Books Antitrust Litig., No. 11-md-02293 (DLC) (S.D.N.Y.): A nationwide class of eBook consumers allege five of the largest book publishers in the United States and Apple conspired to raise the prices of eBooks and restrain competition.
  • In re Optical Disk Drive Prods. Antitrust Litig., No. 3:10-md-2143 RS (N.D. Cal.): An action on behalf of consumers in more than two dozen states against the manufacturers of optical disk drives, the plaintiffs allege defendants conspired to increase the price of ODDs that were sold to original equipment manufacturers. Defendants’ conduct allegedly caused millions of consumer electronics products, such as computers, to be sold at illegally inflated prices.
  • Pecover et al. v. Electronic Arts Inc., No. 3:08-cv-02820-CW (N.D. Cal.): A nationwide certified class of consumers who bought interactive football video games. Plaintiffs allege Electronic Arts entered into a series of exclusive licenses with football intellectual property owners, such as the NFL, in order to lock-up the market. This resulted in increased prices, lower quality games, and reduced consumer choice.

Mr. Friedman has also been extensively involved in the firm’s representation of government entities, successfully recovering hundreds of millions of dollars for these cash-strapped entities. A recent series of cases include government entities seeking to recover monies wrongfully paid due to a scheme McKesson Corp. perpetrated. These cases include:

  • San Francisco Health Plan v. McKesson Corp., No. 1:08-CV-10843-PBS (D. Mass.); State of Utah v. McKesson Corp., No. CV 10-04743 SI (N.D. Cal.); The Commonwealth of Virginia v. McKesson Corp. et al., No. CV-11-02782 SI (N.D. Cal.); State of Oregon v. McKesson Corp., No. CV-11-5384-SI (N.D. Cal.).

From 1997-2000, Mr. Friedman was an Assistant United States Attorney in the Criminal Division of the United States Attorney's Office for the Central District of California (Los Angeles). As an AUSA, Mr. Friedman tried numerous federal cases and prosecuted matters involving investor, bank, and real estate fraud, tax evasion, narcotics trafficking, and money laundering. Prior to joining the U.S. Attorney's office, Mr. Friedman clerked for the Honorable Manuel L. Real, United States District Court Judge, Central District of California.

Mr. Friedman graduated with a B.A. degree in political science from the University of Washington in 1991, where he was a member of the varsity baseball team. Mr. Friedman obtained his J.D., magna cum laude, from Santa Clara University School of Law in 1994, where he was on the Dean's list, an Emery School of Law Merit Scholarship Recipient, and a research assistant to the Dean of the law school. He is licensed to practice law in California and admitted in the Central and Northern Districts and the United States Court of Appeals for the Ninth Circuit.

  link >>

        

Cases and Investigations